The Broken
I think the announcement that the reason the director was not appearing at Frightfest was because he was busy promoting the film in Japan speaks volumes as The Broken really felt like a J-Horror movie in all but it's cast & setting, in particular it struck me as heavily influenced by Kiyoshi Kurosawa - it's resemblance to Pulse (Kairo) was even more pronounced than the obvious 'Body Snatchers' comparisons.
I agree with what's been said; that the story was a bit slight to sustain feature length but I found it visually very impressive.
I agree with what's been said; that the story was a bit slight to sustain feature length but I found it visually very impressive.
-
- Undead Horde
- Posts: 472
- Joined: Sun Feb 17, 2008 1:24 pm
- The Soapmaker
- Undead Horde
- Posts: 453
- Joined: Tue Aug 29, 2006 10:50 am
- Location: London
-
- Frightfest Hardcore
- Posts: 1560
- Joined: Sun Mar 27, 2005 5:54 pm
- Location: A hell of my own making
- Contact:
Um. Really, that's it. There's not a vast amount I can say about it. It looks good, though a little too dark and moody (then again, so was I), there's only one big moment of shock/horror/gore (the shower attack) and the rest of it is mostly buildup with either an underwhelming payoff or no payoff at all.
Made me chuckle that her dad kept going into the toilets at his embassy. Once he washed his hands and walked out, the second time he got spooked because someone was in one of the cubicles ! Err...what did he expect ?
The whole thing didn't make any sense and it all seemed padded out by repeated flashbacks of the saaamme sequences.
Yeah and I agree, she killed a cabbie and deserves locking up.
Thumbs down from me.
The whole thing didn't make any sense and it all seemed padded out by repeated flashbacks of the saaamme sequences.
Yeah and I agree, she killed a cabbie and deserves locking up.
Thumbs down from me.
- Stephen with ph
- Running Zombie
- Posts: 111
- Joined: Tue Aug 26, 2008 6:48 pm
- Location: The garden of England
The Broken
A good looking film that didn't really amount to much - my sense of disappointment appeared to be shared matched by those around me.
But, thinking about it the following morning, it did occur to me that my verdict would probably have been very different if, say, the cast were Korean and the lovingly-shot cityscapes had been Seoul. I'm fairly sure I would have attributed the apparent lack of logic, plot and motivation to the cultural differences which, in my case, help make such films so interesting.
So: I still don't like this film, but I now feel a bit of a hypocrite...
(PS - this isn't an invitation for anyone to express their profound sense of ennui towards J-horror. I know how you feel. We all do.)
But, thinking about it the following morning, it did occur to me that my verdict would probably have been very different if, say, the cast were Korean and the lovingly-shot cityscapes had been Seoul. I'm fairly sure I would have attributed the apparent lack of logic, plot and motivation to the cultural differences which, in my case, help make such films so interesting.
So: I still don't like this film, but I now feel a bit of a hypocrite...
(PS - this isn't an invitation for anyone to express their profound sense of ennui towards J-horror. I know how you feel. We all do.)
- The Soapmaker
- Undead Horde
- Posts: 453
- Joined: Tue Aug 29, 2006 10:50 am
- Location: London
Re: The Broken
I think you're right, but those subtle cultural differences do make the, er, difference. It might've worked as a Korean movie... but it didn't as a British one.Stephen with ph wrote:But, thinking about it the following morning, it did occur to me that my verdict would probably have been very different if, say, the cast were Korean and the lovingly-shot cityscapes had been Seoul. I'm fairly sure I would have attributed the apparent lack of logic, plot and motivation to the cultural differences which, in my case, help make such films so interesting.
-
- Undead Horde
- Posts: 411
- Joined: Mon Sep 25, 2006 10:04 am
I rarely get angry watching a fiction film...but this one had me spitting feathers.
A criminal waste of funding and talent, this had the air of a botched job polished up to try and save it.
The story and interview in the dialies summed it up...a half cocked idea that wasn't allowed to develop and a tightly produced film with no soul.
Yuck...get it away from me and bring me the pills.
A criminal waste of funding and talent, this had the air of a botched job polished up to try and save it.
The story and interview in the dialies summed it up...a half cocked idea that wasn't allowed to develop and a tightly produced film with no soul.
Yuck...get it away from me and bring me the pills.
The Power of THE RIFF compells me!
-
- Running Zombie
- Posts: 122
- Joined: Tue Aug 19, 2008 11:01 pm
- Location: Shepherds Bush
SHORT FILM PLAGIARISM AND LOSING THE WILL TO LIVE !!
Yes, I was so bored, I did a remarkable impression of Bagpuss on more than several occassions during "The Broken". I tried so hard to stay interested, but it just wasn't happening. The story was poorly put together, the script was dull, the acting was lame, it terms of cinematography it was bland, there were no surprises, there was no spark.
What really annoyed me was that during the film the music would indicate that something was going to happen and in my mind I was thinking yeah, Im gonna get a scare, but then............. nothing, then more creepy music and I was thinking ok double bluff, now something is gonna happen .................. nothing.................... more creepy music now something is definitely going to happen................................................. nothing, then more music...................................AHHHHHHHH!
I was so bored I went to the toilet and organised my make-up bag as well as brushing my hair for the sheer thrill of it. Then I went upstairs and bought some ice-cream for my boyfriend counting the steps as I walked up them, thinking that would be more exciting than the film. It was. I even started taking in the foyer decor on the way to the Ben & Jerrys counter to lengthen the time away from Screen 2 as much as possible without my boyfriend wondering if I had deserted him.
Also the short film they showed before is almost identical to a short film I saw years ago as a child. In the good old days they would usually show a short film before the main feature. If you are in my age range (37) you'll remember. Im talking late 70's early 80's. It was a short film called "Don't Panic". The lady on stage did not mention this original film as far as I can remember, which is pretty out of order seeing as it was totally plagiarised and nicked to make the short film we saw on Sunday. At least make a mention of "Don't Panic" if you going to use someone elses stuff like that.
Sorry to be so negative, but it was total Pants. Loved Trailer Park of Terror, Martyrs, The Chaser and others and had a great FrightFest !! See you on Halloween and next August.
What really annoyed me was that during the film the music would indicate that something was going to happen and in my mind I was thinking yeah, Im gonna get a scare, but then............. nothing, then more creepy music and I was thinking ok double bluff, now something is gonna happen .................. nothing.................... more creepy music now something is definitely going to happen................................................. nothing, then more music...................................AHHHHHHHH!
I was so bored I went to the toilet and organised my make-up bag as well as brushing my hair for the sheer thrill of it. Then I went upstairs and bought some ice-cream for my boyfriend counting the steps as I walked up them, thinking that would be more exciting than the film. It was. I even started taking in the foyer decor on the way to the Ben & Jerrys counter to lengthen the time away from Screen 2 as much as possible without my boyfriend wondering if I had deserted him.
Also the short film they showed before is almost identical to a short film I saw years ago as a child. In the good old days they would usually show a short film before the main feature. If you are in my age range (37) you'll remember. Im talking late 70's early 80's. It was a short film called "Don't Panic". The lady on stage did not mention this original film as far as I can remember, which is pretty out of order seeing as it was totally plagiarised and nicked to make the short film we saw on Sunday. At least make a mention of "Don't Panic" if you going to use someone elses stuff like that.
Sorry to be so negative, but it was total Pants. Loved Trailer Park of Terror, Martyrs, The Chaser and others and had a great FrightFest !! See you on Halloween and next August.
BLANCHE: You wouldn't be able to do these awful things to me if I weren't still in this chair!
BABYJANE: BUT YOU ARE BLANCHE! YOU ARE IN THAT CHAIR!
BABYJANE: BUT YOU ARE BLANCHE! YOU ARE IN THAT CHAIR!